Stem cell cloning is not
a new idea. Since 1944 it has been known that existing hair follicles
have the ability to grow new hair when implanted elsewhere.
Recent research shows that bald mice can grow hair after being
implanted with "blank slate" stem cells.
(These are different to the
embryonic stem cells that generate so much controversy).
Stem cell cloning is not real cloning in the true
sense of the word. But, it is very similar because
hundreds of hair follicles can be produced from just one donor
follicle.
(Follicular multiplication or follicular cell regeneration
are more accurate terms).
Follicle hair transplant therapy is still in a stage of research and
testing, and so is not yet
available as an alternative to conventional hair transplants.
However, this treatment
(which is also known as follicular cell implantation) will involve the
following procedure - A scalp biopsy is first taken to obtain a few
healthy hair follicles. (This uses a local anaesthetic and takes about
30 minutes).
The extracted follicles are then dissected to obtain the papilla (see
diagram), each of which contains between 200 and 400 dermal papilla
cells (DPC's).
These cells are then incubated in cultures to produce hundreds of
thousands of new papilla cells. This process takes about 8 weeks.
The DPC's are then implanted (injected) into a bald area of the scalp
and release cytokines (chemical signals) that tell the skin to start
producing new hair follicles.
However,
the process of growing new hair is far more complicated than just that!
A new hair follicle is made from epithelial cells.
But, the growth cycle of a follicle is governed by
DPC's. So, both epithelial cells and DPC's are
needed to produce a follicle.
Also, DPC's don't only originate from the papilla - many migrate from
the dermal sheath (see diagram above) into the
papilla during the hair growth cycle, and then migrate back out again
once the cycle is complete.
The added complexity of epithelial cells and dermal sheath involvement
in the process of creating new follicles has presented additional
problems that must be solved if this type of therapy is ever to work
successfully.
Problems
with stem cell cloning and follicle hair transplants
Whilst stem cell cloning for follicle hair transplants has managed to
produce hair regrowth in about 70% of volunteers in
one very small trial, there are several areas of difficulty concerning
this "therapy of the future."
The culturing technique must preserve the stem
cell's ability to reproduce hair, and ensure that a significant number
of DPC's can be grown within that culture.
Any hair produced must be of an acceptable
standard to the client (i.e., thick, strong, healthy hair growth).
The implantation method must guarantee that
thousands of implantations per client will produce acceptable and
standardised hair growth for the client.
There's a risk that any hair grown might not
survive.
Given that the process requires the
transplantation of perhaps thousands of cells, and involves rapid cell
division, it could potentially cause cancer.
The procedure will be very expensive - the
price will almost certainly be comparable with today's conventional
treatments.
An inconsistent number of follicles may be
produced - even if the same quantity of cells are injected into the
scalp (i.e., as were injected into another area, or in another patient)
hair growth can vary from one area to the next, and from one patient to
another.
Normal hair growth has an even density
(distribution) throughout the scalp. But, transplanted cells can lump
together and then cause hair growth to be patchy.
Regular hair growth is directional (normally
it's in a clockwise direction around the vertex). But the hair grown
from implanted cells could be at any angle. This,
of course, would give a very shabby looking result that's unacceptable
to the patient.
Another approach for using stem cell cloning and follicle hair
transplants is based on the observation that hair loss involves
shrinkage of hair follicles.
(This creates weaker and weaker hair with
each successive growth cycle). The implanted cells could force the existing
follicles to regenerate, and so produce healthy hair growth once again.
This theory is based on trials where hair growth from both implanted
cells and original follicles was observed in mouse
ears.
If the implanted cells can influence existing
follicles, this method might also address the last three problems
mentioned above, since it would involve original follicles that already
exist in an acceptable quantity, density and direction of growth.
However, yet another problem could see implanted cells migrating from
the area of new hair growth, and so lead to alopecia emerging once
again!
It's because of ongoing problems like these that stem cell cloning and
follicle hair transplants have received many different estimates of
when such a therapy might become a reality. These vary from 3
to 8 years, or even longer. And that's of no use to you if
you're suffering from hair loss right now!
It may also be that the stem cell cloning and follicle hair transplant
procedure will not reach the same level of effectiveness that a high
quality conventional transplant may be able to produce.
There is one more area of concern that could influence whether stem
cell cloning and follicle hair transplants will ever become viable
solutions for male pattern baldness - the reason why hair loss happens
in the first place. In other words, why follicles shrivel.
What previous studies and trials have not considered is that the real
reason why scalp follicles shrivel and stop growing healthy hair is skull
expansion.
Unless skull expansion has stopped, this process can, for those
affected by androgenetic alopecia, still influence any
follicle that is growing hair within the male pattern baldness region
of the scalp.
And this obviously includes those follicles that are
trying to grow hair from the DPC's that have been implanted by this new
therapy.
The realisation that skull expansion causes this type of hair loss led
to the development of new
techniques for hair loss.